Whatever point of view you take on the Song of Songs, it’s clearly a difficult piece of writing. Narrowing down exactly what type of literature it is, what the text means and of whom the text is speaking is not easy. That’s why it’s important to have good friends to help you out. Preparing a recent sermon on Song of Songs 8:5-14 meant I could dip in to lots of different people… here’s what I found…

Barry Webb – Five Festal Garments
It’s a real shame Webb’s book is relatively short, only 20 pages on the Song. It’s especially helpful for seeing how the Song fits together and what it’s purpose is. He really focuses on the structural and thematic issues drawn out in the Song, but really it’s too short to be persuaded by his arguments alone, but I guess it points to further reading.
Tom Gledhill – The Message of the SofS (BST)
Gledhill is fairly thorough with the text, drawing out most of the details and discussing the issues. He takes a naturalistic approach and focuses on the human details, but I don’t think really helps to point us to Christ, or really to be that relevant in pointing us to application.
Tremper Longman III – SofS (NICOT)
Longman is technical, but concise, he doesn’t faff around. He opts for a dual approach, but doesn’t really focus any time to showing us Christ. I think his interpretations are a little off in places. But it’s strength is making the technical accessible.
G. Lloyd Carr – The SofS (Tyndale)
Carr gives good discussion to interpretation and opts for the natural/literal approach. I like Carr’s simple word by word approach, which breaks the text down, making it easy to deal with. I found he sets things out plainly without being too dogmatic on issues. Again, fails really to point us to Christ.
C.H. Spurgeon – The Most Holy Place
Not a commentary, rather a collection of sermons. Spurgeon goes heavily on the Typological approach, seeing Christ in everything. But he doesn’t crowbar it, he takes us from Human love to Christ’s love and there is his focus. It’s wordy and poetic, and perhaps doesn’t really engage the text thoroughly, but certainly draws loads out to feed the soul!
Gary Brady – Heavenly Love
Simple, non-technical. Goes for a dual approach of human love pointing to heavenly love. Doesn’t really help to solve textual questions, but goes with a clear meaning and is packed with loads of good illustrations. Helpful at a devotional level to any reader and gives great ideas to the preacher to illustrate and apply.
I guess my big frustration in reading on the Song of Solomon is that nobody seems to interpret it in the way I think it should be! Most commentators seem to opt for a naturalistic approach, which has recently been popularised by Mark Driscoll. While a lot of the old greats like Spurgeon, and folk like Daniel Newman and Mike Reeves seem to opt for a Typological / Allegorical approach.
Personally, the best stuff I’ve found on the Song, wasn’t Driscoll’s series (as he claims!), but Pete Woodcock’s series from Cornerstone Kingston, which genuinely takes a dual approach. I think the way it’s supposed to be taught…