I was on the periphery of a conversation the other day where someone made a quite outlandish statement… “Minority Report is better than Inception”, which was greeted with murmurs of unrest. However, having had some time to reflect on this I’m inclined to agree. We rented Inception the other day, on Blue-Ray, to make the most of it. It was a good film, my wife hated it, but generally good – unique concept, great effects etc. But here’s where I felt it was a let down and where a film like Minority Report trumps it.
Context - Minority Report sets the scene, you know you’re in the future, you’re given an example of ‘pre-crime’ in action, those involved, and a history of pre-crime. The story goes on to give you a feel of what life in the future is like. Inception is set up around the idea of corporate espionage through dreams, but we’re not really told where we are, how or why this technology came to be, or any background to the corporate espionage… we don’t really know who the ‘boss’ is, or why he’s having to work for them (maybe we do? I can’t remember).
Characters - a lot of time in Inception is devoted to unveiling the concept, particularly of the architecture of dreams, and the action contained in the dreams themselves, but little time is devoted to developing the characters. Cobb (DiCaprio) is the main star of Inception, we learn a little bit about his relationship with his wife, helped through his time spent with Ariadne (Ellen Page), but we don’t really know him. I wouldn’t say Minority Report is particularly strong on this, but John Anderton (Cruise) has much more dialogue with a variety of characters, the story line is based around the character more than the concept.
Action - Since we’re in a dream most of the time in Inception, it’s hard to accept the action as being ‘real’, which I think takes away from some of the suspense. Sure they introduce the idea of getting ‘stuck’ in a dream, but the action in Minority Report just seems that much more real. I guess not really having a ‘bad guy’ as such does leave you feeling like you’re not really sure who to root for, and perhaps takes away the suspense of finding out who the ‘bad guy is’.
Don’t want to knock Inception too much… it’s got one of the best closing sequences to a film I’ve seen, up there with the Italian Job! What do you think? Inception? Or Minority Report?